Monday, May 21, 2012
Category Links
2010 Scale Aerobatics NATS – Special Announcement on Sound policy  
 

Executive members of the IMAC BOD, Don Hamilton and Wayne Matthews along with former IMAC President and SACB member, Tom Wheeler met with the Executives of the AMA, Dave Mathewson, Greg Hahn, Ron Morgan and Wayne Yeager. The meeting was held in Toledo Ohio where we discussed, and carefully considered the implications of the present Scale Aerobatics Sound rules and how it applies to the Nationals in Muncie Indiana.

All AMA NATS Scale Aerobatics pilots will be required to fly by the 2011 Scale Aerobatics Sound Rules which will be implemented by Kent Porter, Event Director for the contest. These rules which become effective for 2011 are quoted below.

In addition, the day before the contest begins, the Event Director will be conducting ground sound testing using the AMA’s sound frequency analyzer which will be utilized specifically for data acquisition only and will not affect a pilot’s eligibility to fly at the AMA Scale Aerobatics NATS. There will be no ground sound tests required once the contest officially starts.

The Event Director will have the scoring program modified to account for the various changes regarding 0-10 sound score, non-concurrence of the judges and also the increase in the K value of the sound score.

All participating pilots should be cognizant of the importance of curtailing sound emission from their aircraft and how it affects surrounding neighbors. Proper throttle management from take-off to landing should be exercised diligently.

We would like to thank the executives of the AMA who worked with the IMAC BOD to finalize a solution of having the AMA Scale Aerobatics NATS in Muncie IN for 2010 and onwards.

Listed below are the 2011 AMA Scale Aerobatics Sound Rules which will govern the 2010 Scale Aerobatics NATS:

5.4. In-Flight Judging Criteria for Known and Unknown Sequences.
Judges will evaluate each individual sequence flown in its entirety for overall sound presentation. Each judged Known and Unknown sequence, shall have one “figure” added to the end of the score sheet after individually judged maneuvers. This figure shall be known as the Sound Score. The Sound Score will have a K value dependent on the class flown. Individual class K values are:

- Unlimited 15 K

- Advanced 12K

- Intermediate 9K

- Sportsman 6K

- Basic 3K.

The sound score will be scored on a scale of 10 to 0 with 10 denoting “Very Quiet” and the low end of the scale toward zero denoting “Very noisy”. Whole points will be used for scoring. This sound score will then be multiplied by the K value for the individual class and included in the total flight score for the sequence. Note that each judge’s score is independent of the other(s) and no conferencing on the sound score is required.

If a pilot receives a sound score of three (3) or less for the same sequence from two or more judges, the pilot will be notified of the problem and will be requested by the Contest Director prior to the next round to adjust or modify the aircraft in order to reduce the sound level. If that pilot, after notification, again receives a sound score of three (3) or less for the same sequence from two or more judges, that pilot will be disqualified from further competition at that contest.

Actions: E-mail | Permalink | Comments (7)  

Post Rating

Comments
mattymatt
# mattymatt
Monday, April 19, 2010 12:47 PM
I think this is a great step forward regarding the sound issues as it will allow the flexibility to meet requirements for any IMAC contest, from the local to the National levels.

Great job with this one.

I only have one question. If we are truely concerned about noise for our neighbors, then why have different K factors for sound? The angry neighbor doesn't care if they are flying Basic or unlimited.

Other than that.... GREAT! I look forward to the nats.
mattymatt
# mattymatt
Monday, April 19, 2010 1:19 PM
Nevermind... forgot total K per class so the % is the same.
lazun
# lazun
Tuesday, April 20, 2010 9:52 AM
I find the approach to noise by various organizations completely ridiculous.

Instead of imposing a restriction on aircraft it should be on the fields that may require it. It is ludicrous to impose aircraft to meet a noise restriction if not necessary.

In full scale it is the airports that set the restrictions not the aircraft. Airports restrict certain stage level aircraft to certain hours or certain days. It doesn’t mean if you own an older 727/737 or Lear/Falcon your aircraft is junk. We should be taking the same approach. If your field has issues then set the restriction and conform to it. It should be noted as such in the AMA directory or if an event is held. This way it is the pilot that decides if there aircraft meets the desired noise levels for the field or event.

We are putting the noise restrictions and forcing them onto ourselves, when in reality many areas do not need them. However, their may be the need for even stricter guidelines at certain fields.

I see motor sports, drag strips, motor biking, Harley’s with open hearers making more noise than I can imagine a 150 ever do. It is ironic that a club next to a drag strip is being imposed on noise restrictions while the open headers on racers are heard for miles around. Put the restriction on the area if need be. In town no motor bikes “Harley’s” that make excessive noise between 8pm-8am. Not ban all Harley’s. No dragging after 7pm. Not put mufflers on your dragster.

The best one happened this past summer at an IMAC contest in Goshen, NY, while judging unlimited. We had two flight-lines going. I could not hear the models right in front of me. But 3-4 miles away, 2 o’clock position, I could hear a Pitts Special going through his IAC sequence. Loud as can be! Wide open throttle to gain and sustain his speeds for the pulls, prop pulsing and piercing. The power of aerobatics!! Feel the horsepower!! No one is putting any restrictions on his aircraft. How ironic to be at a Mini-IAC contest talking noise and to see the full scale guys cranking it out in front of the flight line.

Sorry, Sean, your Oracle Bipe, yeah you know, it’s a little too loud during those tumbles. Oh sorry, FedEx, your 727 are to loud so don’t use them as cargo planes. Dude, sorry, your Harley is going to have to be toned down. If model airplanes need to be retrofitted to compete or fly in a noise sensitive area then fine, otherwise stay out of it. Let’s be smart and put the restrictions on fields or areas that need it and not restrict ALL models.
2513
# 2513
Saturday, May 08, 2010 8:15 AM
I have been involved in IMAC for a few years now and in the beginning we had no flight noise policy.
We have evolved to the point where it is needed and can be implemented in a fair manner.
As to your issue of other activities noise footprint...We are a much smaller and therefore an easier to regulate activity.
We dont have the numbers of NASCAR or the political weight of Fed Ex or other large corporations.
So we must regulate ourselves before we get restrictions that we cant live with.
Also,if the club hosting the contest feels the noise rules rules dont apply they can get a waiver for their meet.
Mike S
lazun
# lazun
Thursday, May 20, 2010 9:27 PM
"Also,if the club hosting the contest feels the noise rules rules dont apply they can get a waiver for their meet."

That should be the other way around. Let’s be smart and put the restrictions on fields or areas that need it and not restrict ALL models.
Doodad
# Doodad
Friday, June 25, 2010 1:43 PM
Have I applied correctly for membership in IMAC. I paid my Membership fee at the May Imac contest held at GMARC field in Cumming, GA.

If I need to fill out other forms, Please EM me at LouisandJoan.Brown@Gmail.Com

Thanks

L Brown
#
Wednesday, July 21, 2010 10:00 PM
what does sound have to do with flight

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.
Support our Sponsors!


Privacy Statement  |  Terms Of Use
Copyright 2009 by IMAC